Eat dessert first. Isn’t that what they say? Once you read about the restaurants and cafes below, you’ll never start with an entree again. Getting a key lime pie just right, while also raising the bar, is an immense challenge in Florida. But our picks below were up to the challenge!

Congratulations to all our award-winners! To our readers, get your taste buds ready for the most delicious key lime pies in Miami. Yum!

Originally Published: March 27, 2020 

Florida’s Top 7 Key Lime Pie Restaurants in Miami

Icebox Cafe

This quaint restaurant has a fantastic menu. Everything is fresh and delicious. The dinner menu is great, but the desserts, well they are off the charts! You will definitely want to check out the dessert sampler which includes chocolate cake, carrot cake and key lime pie. Their key lime pie in particular is amazing!

Fireman Derek’s 

This low key spot has very good coffee and fantastic key lime pie! The key lime here is the perfect combination of tart and sweet. The menu also has a big selection of all kinds of other pies, cookies, brownies, donuts, and varied pastries.

Blue Collar 

The key lime pie here is nothing short of incredible! It is definitely a standout item on the menu. They offer lunch, dinner and brunch and everything is made is fresh and with quality ingredients. Blue Collar is definitely a must-try when visiting Miami!

Whisk Gourmet 

This restaurant is a hidden gem in Coral Gables. The key lime pie is one of the best in town. All the food here is incredible, including the homemade potato chips. The service is also fantastic!

Monty’s Raw Bar

Monty’s has a great outdoor dining space near the water! The seafood is fresh and plentiful. The fried seafood sampler platter, the conch salad and the Florida stone crab claws (when in season) are all stars on the menu. The key lime pie and flan are also incredible.

Shooters Waterfront 

Shooters has a great waterfront view and delicious local seafood. You will go for the ambiance and your tastebuds! The desserts are also worth the trip. The key lime pie in particular is spectacular.

A Fish Called Avalon 

The seafood here is nothing short of amazing. This restaurant has the perfect balance of people watching and excellent food. The key lime pie is award-winning and for good reason, it is outstanding!


Hi, I'm Jen and I love to travel, go to the beach and write about all the places I have visited. I also have a bucket list of places I can't wait to try! I've visited Cape Cod every summer since I was a kid and now enjoy traveling to all great beach destinations, including Florida! I have worked in the travel industry for all of my career. I love sharing my experiences of different restaurants and places and helping travelers find the best fit for them!

Comments are closed.