Eat dessert first. Isn’t that what they say? Once you read about the restaurants and cafes below, you’ll never start with an entree again. Getting a key lime pie just right, while also raising the bar, is an immense challenge in Florida. But there’s certainly a number of restaurants that are a cut above. Congratulations to all our award-winners! To our readers, get your taste buds ready for the most delicious key lime pies in Miami.

Florida’s Top 9 Key Lime Pie Restaurants in Miami

Icebox Cafe (1855 Purdy Ave)

Key Lime Pie Review: “Fantastic dinner at a quaint place. We were visiting Miami Beach and happened to find this place when looking for healthy dinner options. It wasn’t necessarily “healthy”, but it was fresh and delicious. The curry chicken was a fave. And the desserts… we got the sampler- chocolate cake, carrot cake and key lime pie. I don’t usually like key lime, but this one was amazing! I recommend this place and make sure you leave room for dessert. And I have to mention the service – very nice!” – TripAdvisor

Kush (2003 North Miami Ave)

Key Lime Pie Review: “The food here was on another level, the burger menu is sensational, the alligator bites are a taste experience (us british dont have much alligator!) and what kush is really really really really famous for is its KEY LIME PIE.

That dessert is a delight to look at, take pics of, tweet about, facebook about and more than anything stuff your face with… we ended up going several times during our break in Miami.” – TripAdvisor Review

Fireman Derek’s World Famous Pies (3435 Main Hwy)

Key Lime Pie Review: “This was the very last stop on our guys trip to Key West and Miami. We just couldn’t leave the state without sampling some key lime pie. We found this place on the way to the airport literally as we were leaving Miami.

I had the very good coffee and key lime pie. The pie was tart and sweet as expected and hit the spot. They have a big selection of pies, cookies, brownies, donuts, and all types of pastries as well. If you have a sweet tooth, this is the place for you!” – TripAdvisor Review

Pink Pie (170 NW 26th St)

Key Lime Pie Review: “I was visiting Wynwood and craving something sweet when I discovered Pink Pie. They make little individual pies with a variety of sweet and savory fillings. I had the key lime pie and it was an excellent balance of sweet and tart. The filling and crust were delicious and it was a perfect two or three bites. The pies are big enough to satisfy but small enough to alleviate guilt. Staff very friendly. Definitely recommend.” – TripAdvisor Review

Blue Collar (6730 Biscayne Blvd)

Key Lime Pie Review: “We also ordered several items from the daily vegetable board (they have roughly 20 items offered each day) – I don’t recall what we ordered, but everything was really good. For dessert, we had Key Lime Pie – not normally my preference, but I figured, when in Florida…Well, this Key Lime Pie was incredible – so much better than any of the others I have tried over the years.” – TripAdvisor Review

Whisk Gourmet (7382 SW 56th Ave)

Key Lime Pie Review: “I’m logging on to TA just to write a review about a chicken salad sandwich and “house chips.” Okay? That should tell you how much I LOVED this little treasure in Coral Gables. The Key Lime Pie is one of the best in town — and that is a HUGE statement for Miami, Florida. Our server was a beautiful, elegant, well-spoken young lady who could not have been nicer.” – TripAdvisor Review

Monty’s Raw Bar (2550 S Bayshore Dr)

Key Lime Pie Review: “Love being able to eat outdoors near the water! The seafood is fresh and plentiful! I have eaten here twice in two days and would return again if coming back to this area for a stay. Try the Fried Seafood Sampler Platter, the Conch Salad, the Florida Stone Crab Claws when in season, the black beans & rice and the Key Lime Pie and Flan!” – TripAdvisor Review

Shooters Waterfront (3003 NE 32 Ave, Fort Lauderdale)

Key Lime Pie Review: “Lobster risotto, shrimp and scallop plate, rib eye, salmon and kids grilled cheese all DELICIOUS! the fresh lobster over risotto was worth every bite, the salmon and couscous was super tasty to the last bite, the rib eye was juicy and those potatoes were the best, the scallop and shrimp would have been magnificent but it came out cold, but no worries the service was so great they took it off our bill, we also had clam chowder that had a bit of bacon that made the dish Devine, what doesn’t bacon make better? The desserts are a MUST we had the banana bread pudding flan that was out of this world and an original, we also had key lime pie, WOW! It’s tart, crunchy, sweet, creamy and wakes up every taste bud a definite must try, you won’t regret it. Everything was A+” – TripAdvisor Review

A Fish Called Avalon (700 Ocean Dr)

Key Lime Pie Review: “Our second visit to this lovely restaurant. Seafood is amazing. A great balance of people watching and excellent food – much better than anything else on the strip. We love this place and booked in as soon as we knew we were returning to Miami. Somehow we saved some space for the key lime pie (award winning) which was outstanding! Our fave place in Miami!” – TripAdvisor Review

We are the #1 Florida vacation rental website. Our mission is to help travelers find and book the perfect rental for their next visit to Florida. Whether it is a week’s trip with your children, a romantic long weekend with your spouse, or a reunion on the beach with a large group of friends - we have Florida vacation rentals to suit every need.

Comments are closed.