Question 1

What is the difference in atmosphere between the Upper, Middle, and Lower Keys?

Accepted Answer

The Upper Key has a relaxed vibe with a lot of nature preserves and parks to see. The Middle Keys have a laid-back vibe along with popular places to snorkel, dive, and swim. The Lower Keys, along with Key West, have an energetic vibe.

Question 2

Which Key is best for nightlife and attractions versus quiet relaxation?

Accepted Answer

The Lower Keys have a vibrant nightlife, while the Middle Keys offer a relaxing atmosphere.

Question 3

How do I choose the right Key to stay on for my vacation goals?

Accepted Answer

One of the simplest ways to choose a Key is to decide which attractions you want to see. Then, choose the Key that gives you the easiest access to those attractions.

Question 4

Are there any lesser-known Keys that offer good rental options?

Accepted Answer

Sugarloaf Key, Little Torch Key, and Tavernier Key are lesser-known Keys with houses and other types of vacation rentals.

Question 5

Which Key is the best home base for fishing, diving, or snorkeling trips?

Accepted Answer

The Middle Key is your best bet for fishing, diving, and snorkeling fun, particularly off the coast of Marathon.

Question 6

What are the "must-do" activities when staying in the Florida Keys?

Accepted Answer

Some “must-do” activities include snorkeling and swimming around the reefs, visiting the Hemingway Home and Museum, touring Marathon Marine Park, and visiting Dolphins Plus Bayside.

Question 7

Are the rentals close to good restaurants, marinas, and public beaches?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Many Florida Keys vacation rentals are close to restaurants, marinas, and public beaches. Some properties are close to shopping areas, state parks, boat rentals, and breweries as well.

Question 8

What is the best way to get around the Keys – is a car necessary?

Accepted Answer

Though there is public transportation like the Freebee Shuttle, renting a car is a great way to take in the sights around the Keys.

Question 9

What are the pros and cons of renting directly from an owner versus a property manager?

Accepted Answer

One pro of renting directly from an owner is flexibility. You may be able to negotiate on rent or fees with a property owner, whereas a property manager isn’t likely to negotiate. However, a property owner may not be as quick as a property manager to address rental issues, including maintenance.

Question 10

What are the best websites for finding "For Rent By Owner" (FRBO) properties in the Keys?

Accepted Answer

Florida Rentals is one of the best websites to find FRBO properties.

Question 11

How can I protect myself from scams when booking directly with an owner?

Accepted Answer

One way to protect yourself is to conduct an address search to ensure the property exists. Also, don’t pay the rent with a gift card, cash, check, or wire transfer. Be suspicious of a large property with lots of amenities and very low rent.

Question 12

Do rentals by owner offer more flexibility on price or stay dates?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Rentals by owner offer more flexibility regarding price and stay dates. While a property management company has to answer to the owners, the owner of a rental can make changes at will.

Question 13

What types of houses are common for rent in the Keys (e.g., stilt homes, bungalows, canal-front homes)?

Accepted Answer

Canal-front homes, bungalows, and cottages are common rentals in the Florida Keys.

Question 14

What is the benefit of renting a house on a canal versus one that is oceanfront?

Accepted Answer

A house with a canal gives you a place to boat and fish in still water right in front of the property. Renting an oceanfront home offers a great view of the ocean, but not a convenient place for fishing and boating.

Question 15

Do most house rentals come with private boat dockage?

Accepted Answer

Yes, many house rentals in the Florida Keys include private docks.

Question 16

Are there large houses available that can accommodate multiple families or big groups?

Accepted Answer

Yes, there are large houses in the Florida Keys suitable for big groups. Use the search filter to find a rental that can accommodate all of your guests.

Question 17

What are the essential amenities for a Keys rental (e.g., boat slip, fish cleaning station, outdoor seating)?

Accepted Answer

Essential amenities for Florida Keys rentals include a patio or deck, boat slip, Wi-Fi, heated pool, and kitchen.

Question 18

Is a private pool a common feature for house rentals in the Keys?

Accepted Answer

Yes, a private pool is a common sight in a description of house rentals in the Keys.

Question 19

What should I look for in terms of parking, especially if I'm bringing a boat trailer?

Accepted Answer

Look at the property’s description to see if there is parking available. Some owners have parking areas for boat trailers. If you don’t see any information about trailer parking, message the property owner to get specifics.

Question 20

Are kitchens in these homes typically well-equipped for cooking a fresh catch?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Along with a fish cleaning station, many rentals have a well-stocked kitchen with appliances for cooking seafood.

Florida Keys Vacation Rentals

Location & Specific Keys