Book Direct & Save - No Booking Fees

Sanibel Island Rentals by Owner

(12 rentals)
Sanibel Island Condo
Sleeps 5, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms
3 reviews

Distance to beach: 50 feet to Pointe Santo Beach

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Beachfront
  • Hot tub
  • Pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Welcome to Sanibel Island Treasure - Pointe Santo B-47, a stunning end-unit retreat offering the ultimate blend of luxury, comfort, and breathtaking scenery. Nestled in the heart of Sanibel Island, this beautifully remodeled condo promises an unforgettable vacation experience for the 2025 rental season.Property...

View all property information

Featured review

"Wonderful beach front condo"

We had a wonderful stay at this condo. Beautifully furnished, view of the gulf, lovely pool and hot tub. Many amenities, beach chairs and beach towels provided, roof top deck with spectacular views. ...

See all reviews

$489
avg per night
Sanibel Island Condo
Sleeps 6, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms
2 reviews

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Beachfront
  • Oceanfront
  • Pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Condo, 2 Bedrooms + Den, 2 Baths, (Sleeps 6) Located on Sanibel Island, our unit at the Sanddollar is a spacious 1,660 sq. ft. Luxuriously furnished gulf front condominium. Two bedrooms plus den, 2 full bathrooms. Our unit has a 26' screened-in porch overlooking the ocean. Exceptional view of the...

View all property information

Featured review

"Wonderful"

The condo was wonderful with everything you could need. Loved the view from the deck. Can sit , watch, and listen to the waves rolling in. ( so calming) Would definitely come back!!

See all reviews

$522
avg per night
Sanibel Island Townhome
Sleeps 6, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms
6 reviews

Distance to beach: 1000 feet to Sanibel Bay

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Spacious well-equipped property, a five-minute stroll to the Bay. on Sanibel Island's east coast. Lots of room as the property hosts 2 bedrooms & 2 baths on the main floor and 2 bedrooms, and 1 full bath upstairs for visiting family & friends. It is a townhouse with a shared heated swimming...

View all property information

Featured review

"Beautiful Sanibel"

This townhouse comes with it all!! We especially loved the bikes that Mary provides and ALL the beach gear she provides as well. The location was perfect and the bay was only about 5 minutes from the house....

See all reviews

$149
avg per night
Sanibel Island Condo
Sleeps 6, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms
1 review

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Beachfront
  • Oceanfront
  • Pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Loggerhead Cay is your perfect Sanibel escape — just steps from the beach, all condos under Caihlin are beautifully decorated, and packed with thoughtful touches. After a day of shelling, biking, or lounging by the oversized pool, come home to a spacious, serene retreat. Whether you’re exploring...

View all property information

Featured review

"Clean, comfy and perfect!!!"

Wow. All I can say is wow. From the first message I sent inquiring about the condo to the text I received at the end of our stay regarding checkout instructions, the experience renting and staying at Caihlin’s...

See all reviews

$341
avg per night
New
Sanibel Island House
Sleeps 6, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms

Distance to beach: 0.3 miles to BEACH ACCESS 2

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Hot tub
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

An exceptional new vacation rental property has just become available. This stunning 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom Florida cottage is truly a decorator's dream, having recently completed a full renovation in 2026.The home is equipped with premium finishes, modern appliances, and smart TVs throughout....

View all property information

$281
avg per night

Why Choose FloridaRentals.com?

No booking or service fees

No Booking or Service Fees

Save up to 25% compared to other websites - no hidden costs.

Connect Directly with Hosts

Connect Directly with Hosts

Book with confidence and get the best rates.

Florida's #1 vacation rental listings site

Florida's #1 Vacation Rental Site

Trusted by millions - your go-to for the perfect Florida getaway.

Sanibel Island House
Sleeps 10, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms
1 review

Distance to beach: 1 miles to Sanibel Beachs

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Hot tub
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Escape to the beauty of Sanibel Island with a stay at our exquisite 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom ranch-style home. With 2,100 sq ft of living space, this modern and meticulously designed property offers a perfect blend of comfort and luxury.Key Features:Spacious 4 bedrooms: Master bedroom with a king...

View all property information

Featured review

"Best Location and Wonderful Retreat!"

We typically stay in Fort Myers Beach but our favorite spot was washed away by the storm. We were so excited to find out Nate has a new property on Sanibel. The location is so desirable, island living at...

See all reviews

$351
avg per night
New
Sanibel Island House
Sleeps 8, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

This newly completed Florida cottage, located in the sought-after Beachview neighborhood, offers a premier luxury experience. Finished in late 2025, this four-bedroom, three-bathroom residence features meticulous attention to detail throughout.The property includes an extensive lanai with outdoor...

View all property information

$415
avg per night
Sanibel Island House
Sleeps 10, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms
3 reviews

Distance to beach: 1 miles to Private Beach

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Hot tub
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Brand New post-Hurricane Ian Ranked Top 25 Beach in the WorldThis fabulous 4 bedroom private estate is on Sanibel's premier east end. No detail has been overlooked in this coastal modern, pet-friendly, waterfront home.This coastal modern home is inviting and comfortable, from its stylish...

View all property information

Featured review

"Fabulous vacation at coral sea"

We absolutely loved our stay. Everything was thoughtfully provided and appliances and furnishings were top notch. Our family had so much fun with the games and bocee court. The pool and hot tub were...

See all reviews

$571
avg per night
Sanibel Island Condo
Sleeps 4, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms
7 reviews

Distance to beach: 150 yards to Loggerhead Cay is on the beach

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Oceanfront
  • Pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Note: All photos are Pre-Ian. Loggerhead Cay is a top rated complex, on the beach, with quiet surroundings. First floor convenience...walk out from the Lanai to the pool and beach. Great for a couple, or fits four persons. 2 Bedrooms, each with it's private bathroom. Private bedrooms. Premium...

View all property information

Featured review

"Relaxing Paradise"

We have loved staying at Loggerhead Cay for years but this year had to switch to a different condo. We found #441 to be very comfortable. Everything we needed was right there in the condo from chairs...

See all reviews

$214
avg per night
Sanibel Island House
Sleeps 2, 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom

Distance to beach: 0.2 miles to Many

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Hot tub
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Private and Peaceful Lakefront Suite for Rent – Sanibel Island (East End).About the Suite & Living Arrangement:This private suite is attached to a home occupied by two long-term Sanibel residents. One is retired and home part-time, and the other works five days a week on the island....

View all property information

$100
avg per night
Sanibel Island House
Sleeps 6, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Welcome to Beautiful Sanibel Island! We warmly invite you to unwind and enjoy your stay in our charming oasis. Relax on the dock, take a refreshing dip in the private pool, or simply bask in the tranquility of our property. For those seeking adventures, inquire about private fishing charters, island...

View all property information

$588
avg per night
Sanibel Island House
Sleeps 6, 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms
7 reviews

Distance to beach: 2 miles to Bowman Beach

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Pet friendly
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Pristine, lovely home in quiet subdivision, 400 yards from the Gulf of Mexico and the spectacular beaches on Sanibel Island’s west end. Beaches on this area of the island are relatively quiet, with few people; Captiva's beaches also are close by across Blind Pass, within walking distance. ...

View all property information

Featured review

"Sanibel Dreaming"

I had a wonderful time in Sanibel, much of this due to Heidi's home on Pine ave. The previous reviewer said it all: the house is perfectly outfitted for a great vacation. The home is light-filled, comfy,...

See all reviews

$140
avg per night
Full map
Map