1st I want to thank all our past guests for their great reviews.
Bay Harbour Starfish is a luxury condo overlooking a large boat basin with views of the Atlantic Ocean. Situated in Lower Matecumbe Key, Islamorada, the Sport Fishing Capital of the World. This very spacious 3 bedroom, 2 and half bath condo has been decorated in Tommy Bahama style with a large living and dining area, including a wet bar. The kitchen is equipped for family cooking and has a writing desk for your convenience. The Master suite is very roomy and in suite bath with large jetted soaking tub and seperate shower and walkin closet. This bedroom has sliding glass doors leading out to the expanse screened in lanai overlooking the boat basin. Two guest bedrooms have Queen sized beds and are designed in a tropical motif. The living and dining areas also lead out to the screened in patio, where you can dine alfresco and watch the boats coming into the basin. There is a 30' boat slip included with electric and water, fish cleaning stations are setup by the dock. There is a locking storage area in the garage for you to put all of your boating gear or bikes. The storage area includes a freezer for your bait and catch. The facility includes tropical landscaping, a heated pool and spa, large gym with workout equipment and a club house. There are grills for you to use and the tennis and basketball courts are lighted. Rental license 24-261.
Registration Number: VR-260
Unique Benefits
As soon as we opened the front door we fell in love with our condo. The bright open and warm feeling with the patio doors all across the living room is amazing. This is a small gated community which is very quiet and relaxing.
Why Kids Love It
Kids love catching snapper off the dock or just seeing the lovely fish swim by. Frequent visits by Manatees is always exciting to see. The pool is a good entertainment and there is room to explore in this gated community.
Swimming Pool, Hot tub, Heater, Shower, Clothes Dryer, Washing Machine, Living Room, Pantry Items, Video Library, 4 TV's, workout room, gas grills,
No Booking or Service Fees
Save up to 25% compared to other websites - no hidden costs.
Connect Directly with Hosts
Book with confidence and get the best rates.
Florida's #1 Vacation Rental Site
Trusted by millions - your go-to for the perfect Florida getaway.
| Rate Period | Nightly | Weekend Night | Weekly | Monthly | Min Stay |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nov 30 - Dec 14 2025 | $359 | 7 nights | |||
Dec 15 - Dec 22 2025 | $359 | 7 nights | |||
Dec 23 2025 - Jan 03 2026 | $400 | 7 nights | |||
Jan 04 - Jan 23 2026 | $360 | 7 nights | |||
Jan 24 - Feb 28 2026 | $398 | 7 nights |
Fees:
Notes:
Cleaning Fee $275
Property Damage Protection $500
Tax ID:
VR-260
Last updated on December 03, 2025
warm retreat
Bay Harbor was delightful, from the condo unit to the grounds and amenities. We used the hot tub, exercise room and swimming pool, When we left there was 76 degrees, returned to 20 degrees in Pennsylvania.
Stayed: January 2025 Submitted: January 21, 2025
Host response
"Thank you, Wendy, for the review. Yes, the Keys are one of the very few warm spots in the country this week."
Michael S. Davis & Deanna D.Great Home Away From Home!
Perfect location! Our family had a great week and we will definitely come back. Condo is well furnished, clean and plenty of space. Kitchen is well stocked with essentials. Pool was very refreshing. The owners were very good about getting back with us if we had a question.
Stayed: August 2022 Submitted: August 31, 2022
Craig S.Gorgeous place
Thank you so much for letting us stay at your condo! It is absolutely gorgeous and you have everything there we needed and more. The location was perfect and our children enjoyed the tennis courts, pool, and hot tub on site. We can't wait to go back again!Thanks again!!
Stayed: November 2020 Submitted: November 22, 2020
Yes, the boat slip is included with the rental. The slip will handle up to a 34' boat and has fresh water and electricity at the slip.

Member since 2019