Escape to the Florida Keys and experience waterfront living at its finest in this beautifully renovated 5-bedroom, 3-bath vacation home located in desirable Cudjoe Gardens, just 17 miles from Key West and minutes from world-class boating, fishing, diving, and snorkeling.
This spacious 3,500-square-foot ground-level home sits on a prime 120-foot waterfront lot along a wide, deep ocean-side canal with direct boating access to both the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf. Completely renovated in 2019 as a private second home, the property combines coastal elegance, comfort, and functionality for families, fishing groups, boating enthusiasts, and extended stays.
The home's open-concept layout features a fully equipped custom quartz and hardwood kitchen with premium Samsung appliances, a large dining area, and a comfortable Great Room overlooking the water. Guests also enjoy the unique "Mermaid Club" foyer bar, complete with a wet bar, ice maker, reverse-osmosis filtered water, coffee station, and breakfast area.
The main residence includes three king bedrooms and two bathrooms, including a spacious primary suite with a private bath and makeup center. A separate private suite offers additional privacy with a king bedroom, queen bedroom, full bathroom, and a second fully equipped kitchen—ideal for multi-generational families, couples traveling together, or guests seeking extra space.
Step outside to discover what makes this property truly special. The expansive 14' x 40' covered waterfront porch serves as a second living and dining area, complete with comfortable seating, outdoor dining for up to 10 guests, a fire table, fans, retractable sunshades, and a 7-person spa overlooking the canal.
The waterfront deck sits just feet from the water and features a fish-cleaning station, fish light, gas grill, Louisiana pellet smoker, swimming ladder, outdoor rinse station, dockside seating, and protected dockage for boats of various sizes. The canal offers calm, deep-water access and includes 50-amp shore power, freshwater hookups, dock cleats, bumpers, and easy access to nearby marinas.
Surrounded by lush tropical landscaping, the private palm and orchid garden includes a hammock, Adirondack chairs, ambient lighting, and a unique bamboo-enclosed outdoor "Mermaid Shower" with hot and cold water overlooking the canal.
Whether you're spending your days offshore fishing, diving Looe Key Reef, exploring Key West, or simply relaxing by the water with family and friends, this exceptional Keys retreat provides the perfect setting for an unforgettable stay.
Property Highlights
• 3,500 sq. ft. waterfront home
• 5 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms
• Sleeps up to 10 guests comfortably
• Ground-level residence
• Renovated in 2019
• 120 feet of waterfront seawall
• Wide 10-foot-deep ocean-side canal
• 2 fully equipped kitchens
• 7-person spa/hot tub
• Private palm and orchid garden
• Mermaid Club wet bar and coffee center
• Fiber optic Wi-Fi throughout property
• Smart TVs throughout home
• Washer and dryer
• Large outdoor living and dining spaces
• Gas grill and Louisiana pellet smoker
• Fish-cleaning station and fish light
• Marina access nearby
• Boat-friendly with dockage and shore power
• Off-street parking for vehicles and trailers
• Pet consideration available upon request
• 28-day minimum rental
Bedroom Configuration
Bedroom 1 – King Bed (Private Suite Master)
Bedroom 2 – King Bed (Main House Primary Suite with Private Bath)
Bedroom 3 – King Bed (Waterfront Bedroom)
Bedroom 4 – King Bed (Main House Guest Bedroom)
Bedroom 5 – Queen Bed (Private Suite Guest Room)
Unique Benefits
• Rare 120-foot waterfront lot with protected deep-water dockage
• Direct access to world-renowned fishing, diving, lobstering, and boating destinations
• Separate guest suite with private kitchen and bath
• Expansive outdoor living spaces designed for entertaining
• 7-person spa overlooking the water
• Private tropical garden with outdoor shower
• Marina located within the canal system
• Ideal setup for boat owners and fishing enthusiasts
• Fiber optic internet and multiple Smart TVs for extended stays
• Ground-level design with easy accessibility
Why Kids Love It
• Watching fish and marine life from the dock
• Swimming and snorkeling right from the seawall
• Spacious backyard and tropical garden to explore
• Relaxing in the spa after a day on the water
• Fun "Mermaid Club" art board and gathering space
• Fishing directly from the property
• Spotting boats traveling through the canals
• Family game nights in the Great Room
Located in the quiet waterfront community of Cudjoe Gardens on Cudjoe Key, this home offers the perfect balance between peaceful island living and convenient access to the attractions of the Lower Florida Keys.
Situated just before Mile Marker 21 and only 17 miles from Key West, guests can enjoy easy day trips to historic Old Town, Duval Street, Mallory Square, and the area's famous dining, nightlife, and attractions while returning each evening to a relaxing waterfront retreat.
The location is highly sought after among anglers, divers, and boaters due to its quick access to the Atlantic Ocean, Gulf waters, Looe Key Reef, American Shoal Lighthouse, and numerous offshore and backcountry fishing grounds.
• Cudjoe Gardens Marina
• Canal-front walking and biking routes
• Neighborhood waterfront views
• Local boating access points
• Sunset viewing throughout the community
• Square Grouper Bar & Grill
• Broil Restaurant
• Kiki's Sandbar
• My New Joint
• Boondocks Grille & Draft House
• The Fish House
• Geiger Key Marina Restaurant
• Latitudes (Key West)
• Blue Heaven (Key West)
• Half Shell Raw Bar (Key West)
• The outdoor dining table offers a beautiful view straight down the intersecting canal, creating incredible sunset views almost every evening.
• Bring your boat—the dock is designed to accommodate a variety of vessel sizes and provides calm, protected mooring.
• Early mornings in the hammock with coffee from the Mermaid Club are a guest favorite.
• Looe Key Reef is one of the best snorkeling and diving locations in the Florida Keys and is only minutes away by boat.
• The private suite is perfect for grandparents, another family, or guests who appreciate extra privacy.
• Lobster season, reef fishing, flats fishing, and offshore trolling opportunities are all easily accessible from this location.
No Booking or Service Fees
Save up to 25% compared to other websites - no hidden costs.
Connect Directly with Hosts
Book with confidence and get the best rates.
Florida's #1 Vacation Rental Site
Trusted by millions - your go-to for the perfect Florida getaway.
| Rate Period | Nightly | Weekend Night | Weekly | Monthly | Min Stay |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Aug 03 - Aug 31 2026 | $7,500 | 28 nights | |||
Oct 02 - Oct 30 2026 | $6,500 | 28 nights | |||
Nov 02 - Nov 30 2026 | $6,500 | 28 nights | |||
May 02 - May 30 2027 | $6,500 | 28 nights | |||
All other dates | $6,500 | 27 nights |
Fees:
Notes:
Pet with permission
Discounted rates available for small group.
28 day minimum per Monroe County Law
Covered parking; space for boat trailer
Protected dockage: 90' of boat bumpers and cleats available for your use, as well as shore power if needed at $500 additional.
Tax ID: State of Florida #AF1314605101; Monroe County #5089440
Last updated on June 19, 2026
J.P. G.Best Rental Property in the Keys
I began visiting this property in ~1998 and get back there as often as I can.It is a wonderful house, beautifully decorated, with convenient deep water access to the best fishing/fly-fishing (minutes from the house) in North America. The neighborhood is quiet, classy, and ~20 from Key West.There is a full service marina right down the canal on the way out to the fishing grounds, and the canal is clean with good tidal flow. The wife loves lounging in then garden area and using the hot tub and outdoor shower. The kids love swimming and snorkeling in the gin clear water right off the back deck, and they got a real kick out of watching the manatees drink out of the garden hose!The best part is Alan and Nancy are two of the nicest, most accommodating people on the planet.You will not regret booking a stay here.
Stayed: June 2024 Submitted: June 19, 2026
Host response
"JP, We've always loved having you here. Thanks for the kind words."
Patricia A. H.Best stay ever in Cudjo Key
Spacious so comfortable beautiful sun porch gorgeous grounds all Key West style Jimmy Buffet probably would have stayed here!!
Stayed: April 2026 Submitted: June 18, 2026
Host response
"Thank you Patti. Hope you and your friends will return next year ! We appreciate your love for CudjoeHouse!"
Cudjoe Paradise
Cudjoe House has every amenity you can imagine. We have been there most months, but August is a favorite with opening season for lobster. There is on-site trailer parking and dock for the boat. There is shore power, hose at dock to wash down gear and a grill, hammock, jacuzzi and lots of lounging spaces to enjoy the outdoors as well as indoors. We love jumping in the canal, swimming in the cool Atlantic water and watch the coral edge for colorful marine life.There are often manatees meandering by, and lots of yellow tail and bait fish off of the dock.There is a beautifully appointed kitchen in the main house and a 2nd in the attached apartment. There's a large dining table, seating for a crowd, beautiful wall mounted tv... comfy space to relax and enjoy your family and guests.All the beds are large and comfortable, with lots of closet space and dressers. I always think I have moved into someone's private home, and am house-sitting while they are away....no detail is missing.Then there's the many palms covered with blooming orchids, a comfy hammock, and usually a beautiful breeze to nap or tackle a key-west themed novel. Don’t forget to visit the colorful artsy bar inside, and collect a cold drink before settling in the hammock!Can’t wait to return!
Stayed: August 2024 Submitted: June 17, 2026
Host response
"We can't wait for your return either! Thank you for the amazing review. We take pleasure hosting guests like you"
It doesn't get better than this
This canal-front home in Cudjoe Key is absolutely beautiful. The owners have thoughtfully incorporated many custom-made features that make the home both unique and exceptionally comfortable. The décor is elegant and tasteful, creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere throughout.The waterfront setting is peaceful and relaxing, making it the perfect place to enjoy everything the Florida Keys has to offer. A truly wonderful property that is impeccably maintained and highly recommended.We have been going here for years and look forward to each and every trip. It definitely offers that home away from home feel as soon as you walk in the front door.
Stayed: May 2026 Submitted: June 12, 2026
Host response
"What a wonderful review. We treasure you as tenants. Thank you and hope to see you again soon."
Debbie F.Great place
The house is exactly as pictured. We lived on the outdoor deck! Easy in and out with kayaks on the canal, awesome sunsets, Nancy’s garden is heaven to read in late afternoon, kitchen set up for people who love to cook! They respond immediately to all questions to boot. Booking again! We love Nancy and Alan’s house and them!
Stayed: January 2026 Submitted: June 11, 2026
Host response
"Oh Debbie! We are so pleased you've found your happy place at Cudjoe House. We look forward to your reports from the garden every winter. Thank you for taking time to review."
Adam A.Amazing keys trip!!
Can not say enough how amazing the experience was about our Lower keys vacation! The home is a water front paradise featuring all the amenities of a true key west vibe. Conveniently located within golf cart range or walking distance to some of our favorite, iconic restaurants. Weather your coming to unplug and just relax or fish/ dive the keys this vacation home is your ultimate destination spot! Can’t wait for our next adventure
Stayed: July 2025 Submitted: June 11, 2026
Host response
"Thank you Adam! You were amazing tenants and we are so happy you enjoyed our home."
Brian M.Huge Deepwater Dock and Beautiful Keys Style Home!
I have a Catana 50 sailing catamaran that is 26’ wide and I had plenty of room in the canal to turn around and ample dock space. The water in the canal is gin clear with very little current so I was able to easily clean her bottom. Adjacent to the dock is a private outdoor hot water shower to rinse off in. The porch is oversized and flows naturally into the house. Inside is perfectly appointed with a gourmet kitchen and beautiful art throughout the house. Everything is so well thought out and incredibly comfortable!
Stayed: September 2024 Submitted: June 10, 2026
Host response
"Thank you Brian! we hope you'll be able to return again soon. Your boat looks amazing in the canal and you were a pleasure to communicate with during your stay."
TonyThe Warren family
We have visited several times . We thoroughly enjoyed everything about this place. Very clean and nice owners. Our favorite place to hang out was the back porch and deck! Highly recommend to spend time here.
Stayed: November 2024 Submitted: June 10, 2026
Host response
"So happy you enjoyed our Cudjoe House. It is always a true pleasure to have your family there!"
Member since 2026